If a contractor took your money and did not deliver, two options come up again and again: write to the contractor, or dispute the charge with your card issuer. They are not the same thing and one does not replace the other. This is general information, not legal advice. What applies to you depends on your contract, how you paid and where you live, and neither route guarantees a refund.
The differences at a glance
- Who receives it. A refund letter goes to the contractor. A card dispute goes to your card issuer, the bank that issued the card, not to the contractor.
- What it asks for. A letter asks the business to refund you or finish the work. A dispute asks the issuer to review the charge under its dispute process. The issuer investigates; it does not automatically side with you.
- Who can use it. Anyone can write a letter, however they paid. A card dispute depends on having paid by card, and the rules differ for credit and debit cards.
- Deadlines. A letter has no legal deadline of its own: a reply-by date you choose is a request. Card disputes have time limits set by federal rules and by the card network, and a letter to the contractor does not pause them.
- Rules behind it. A card dispute follows a defined procedure. A letter follows whatever your contract and local rules say about notice, which varies.
What a refund letter does
A letter records what you agreed, what you paid, what happened and what you are asking for, and gives the business a clear chance to answer. It can also be useful later, because it shows you tried to resolve the problem directly. It cannot compel a refund or decide whether you are owed money. Our free refund request letter template shows a structure you can edit.
What a card dispute does
For a credit card, the federal billing-error rules cover charges for services that were not delivered as agreed. They do not cover disagreements about the quality of services you accepted. The procedure generally works like this, according to the FTC: Using credit cards and disputing charges (with sample letter) and the CFPB: Federal billing-error rules and interpretations:
- Your written notice must reach the issuer within 60 days after it sent the first statement showing the charge, at the address for billing inquiries on your statement.
- The issuer must acknowledge the notice in writing within 30 days and resolve the dispute within two complete billing cycles, and no later than 90 days after receiving it.
- While it investigates, you do not have to pay the disputed amount, but you still pay the undisputed part of the bill.
An issuer may also use the card network's own dispute rules. Under Visa's published rules, for services not received the dispute generally must be processed within 120 days of the transaction or of the last date you expected the services, with an outer limit of 540 days from the transaction. See Visa: Network rules (section 11.10.2; confirm your issuer's deadline) (section 11.10.2, edition of April 2026). Other networks have their own rules, and your issuer can tell you which apply and what its own deadline is. For the full walkthrough, see how to dispute a credit card charge for services not rendered.
Do you have to write to the contractor first?
It depends on which rule applies, which is one reason to ask your issuer:
- For a federal billing-error notice about services not delivered, the rule's official commentary says you do not have to contact the merchant first, and the FTC says you can contact the issuer and the seller at the same time.
- Visa's published rules say that before the issuer may start a services-not-received dispute, the cardholder must attempt to resolve it with the merchant.
- A separate federal rule on claims and defenses, which can matter for quality disputes, requires a good-faith attempt to resolve the dispute with the merchant, among other conditions. See CFPB: Credit card claims and defenses, including conditions and exceptions.
A dated written request to the contractor can help show that you tried. Do not let waiting for a reply use up the card deadline, though.
Using both
The two are not alternatives, and many people do both. A common order is to check the card deadline first, send the issuer your notice in time, and send the contractor a short, factual written request as well. Keep copies of everything you send and note the dates. If the contractor offers a refund while a dispute is open, ask your issuer how it wants you to handle that.
If you paid by debit card, Zelle, check or cash, the card rules above may not apply in the same way. Ask your bank what protections and deadlines cover your payment. See the Zelle guide, and what to check if the contractor does not reply.
A quick way to think about it
- Paid by credit card: check your statement date and the issuer's notice address first. The letter and the dispute can run side by side.
- Paid another way: ask your bank or payment service what it offers, and a letter to the contractor is likely your main direct step.
- Unsure about the work itself: a quality disagreement about work you accepted is treated differently from work not delivered. Ask your issuer how it applies.
A fictional example
Dana (a made-up person) pays $3,500 by credit card as a deposit for a deck. The start date passes and the contractor stops answering. Dana finds the statement that first showed the charge, sees that the 60-day period is still open, and sends the issuer a written notice at the billing-inquiries address. Dana also emails the contractor a short factual refund request and keeps both copies and the dates. The issuer investigates under its process, and what happens next depends on the facts and on what the issuer and the contractor each say. Nothing here is assured.
Before you decide
Gather your records with the evidence checklist, and for the wider picture read what to do after a contractor takes a deposit. An attorney or your state consumer office can advise on your own situation. If you'd rather answer a few questions and get a draft letter with a dated timeline filled in from your details, the optional letter pack does that. It prepares materials for you to review, edit and send yourself, and you do not need it to contact your issuer or any agency. See the fictional example pack first.